OH-9: Marcy Kaptur Earmark Hypocrisy, Gives Taxpayer Dollars to Major Donors
Over the Independence Day holiday weekend, the New York Times published a story that I didn’t see until today. Rep. Kaptur has no problem finding creative ways to violate the US House’s supposed ban on earmarks:
TOLEDO, Ohio — Just one day after leaders of the House of Representatives announced a ban on earmarks to profit-making companies, Victoria Kurtz, the vice president for marketing of a small Ohio defense contracting firm, hit on a creative way around it.
To keep the taxpayer money flowing, Ms. Kurtz incorporated what she called the Great Lakes Research Center, a nonprofit organization that just happened to specialize in the same kind of work performed by her own company — and at the same address.
Now, the center — which intends to sell the Pentagon small hollow metal spheres for body armor that the Defense Department has so far declined to buy in large quantities and may never use — has $10.4 million in new earmark requests from Representative Marcy Kaptur, Democrat of Ohio.
The congresswoman, who has received tens of thousands of dollars in campaign contributions from Ms. Kurtz’s family and her business’s lobbyists, thought the quickly hatched nonprofit organization was a convenient solution.[...]
The proposed earmarks are among dozens — totaling more than $150 million — from around the country that would indirectly benefit profit-making companies, according to an examination by The New York Times of House appropriation requests submitted after the new rule was imposed in March.
Adopted because of repeated scandals over wasteful spending — the bridges to nowhere and expensive pet projects like a water-taxi service — the ban was intended to help eliminate earmark abuses. Critics say spending on earmarks, which added $16 billion to the federal budget last year, diverts money from higher priorities, typically does not require competitive bids and is often directed to experimental research that will never be used.
But given the appeal of free government money, the fees that lobbyists can earn by helping businesses grab a handful of it and the persistence of lawmakers in trying to satisfy constituents or donors, the pay-to-play culture in Washington has once again proved hard to suppress.
And the liberal Toledo Blade, which has no problem with ear marks in principle, still concedes that this situation smells rotten:
Much of the tea-flavored criticism of Miss Kaptur, the longest-serving woman in Congress, is off the wall. She generally has represented Toledo and northwest Ohio well during her 14 House terms. In this instance, though, her strenuous election-year efforts on behalf of a well-connected set of recipients are too clever by half.
In Ohio, if it is “stimulus”, “Third Frontier,” or money to shell non-profits, it is ALL pork and a way for Kaptur to use her power to benefit her major contributors at your expense. And appropriations will ALWAYS be subject to political considerations, regardless of what feel-good “bans” Kaptur and Congressional Democrats support.
Kaptur consistently receives an embarrassing, failing grade from Citizens Against Government Waste.
- OH-9: An Update on Marcy Kaptur’s Earmark Corruption
- Marcy Kaptur and Charlie Wilson, Members of the Stupak 11 which Requested $4.7 billion in Earmarks
- Porker of the Month: Rep. Marcy Kaptur
- Ted Strickland Ready to Use Taxpayer Dollars to Kill Unborn Babies?
- Republicans Want to Reform Contract Bidding Process, Save Millions of Taxpayer Dollars